4.5
2000+ Ratings
Pizza & Shakes
4.5 x (2,000+) • Pizza • American • Italian • $ • Info
209 West 57th Street, New York, NY 10019
Pizza & Shakes in Midtown West, Manhattan, is a pizza restaurant known for its customizable dining experience, particularly popular during the evening hours. Guests can enjoy a variety of unique pizzas such as ... More
Pizza & Shakes in Midtown West, Manhattan, is a pizza restaurant known for its customizable dining experience, particularly popular during the evening hours. Guests can enjoy a variety of unique pizzas such as the Country Style Pizza and the Quatreto Pizza, which are often ordered together. Beyond their creative pizza offerings, the menu also features a selection of indulgent gelato and ice cream shakes with flavors like Strawberry and Dark Chocolate. For those looking for something different, there's also an assortment of sandwiches named after Italian cities. The restaurant holds a customer rating of approximately 4.2. Less
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"The #11 is my absolute favorite. It sounds silly but I always order from here on a bad day, because something about it always makes me feel better! I don’t know how they do it, but these are so delicious!!!! There are many pizzas out there, but this one is always 10/10 stars for me. So thank you! ✨😋 don’t forget to order a shake too!"
• Hannah J. • 05/01/24
"OK I will admit that I have a flair for the drama...but let me tell you...this is some of the best pizza...EVER! It is so flavorful and packs just the right amount of tang and spice...it is really good!!!!"
• Ricardo C. • 02/15/24
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
Every Day
10:30 AM - 11:00 PM
Featured items
Chefs Selection Pizzas
Make Your Own Pizza
Ice Cream Shakes
Gelato Shakes
Sandwiches
- Rating and reviews
4.5
•2000+ Ratings •
92 Reviews
Henry P.• 02/06/25It was Amazing, Fresh Ingredients with Awesome Taste!!!
Dion L.• 01/22/25Great pizza
Stacey B.• 11/28/24Delicious combinations and really fresh ingredients. Very friendly workers make it even better!
Lauren C.• 11/07/24yummy flavors
Hernan F.• 07/08/24best pizza
mag L.• 06/29/24satisfied
Ricardo C.• 05/01/24really good pizza I love it
Ollie H.• 05/21/24Fabulous, fresh, quick, value for money, amazing
Lauren C.• 05/04/24yummy
Nnenna B.• 04/19/24First time! I am a huge fan!
Chase D.• 04/08/24great base, lovely cheese
Ricardo C.• 03/28/24OMG the pizza is so good...not 1 but THREE of my friends now order from here based OK my recommendation and of course the delicious pizza.
Ricardo C.• 03/22/24Soooo good 🍕 🍕 🍕 🍕 🍕
Ricardo C.• 03/16/24Really good pizza!
Stacey B.• 02/19/24My order was ready when I arrived and everything was delicious. Service was very polite and efficient.
Devin C.• 02/17/24Very good, very different taste! I devoured it!
Ricardo C.• 02/15/24OK I will admit that I have a flair for the drama...but let me tell you...this is some of the best pizza...EVER! It is so flavorful and packs just the right amount of tang and spice...it is really good!!!!
VICTORIA R.• 02/10/24Quick delivery and before estimated time.
Jeremy L.• 02/06/24Thank you very much
David A.• 02/03/24Delicious.
Amir M.• 01/27/24Delicious
Tarsha L.• 12/01/23Fresh pizza! Yummy shakes!
Danielle C.• 12/13/23absolutely delicious
Sara D.• 12/11/23Great
Lynn H.• 12/03/23Love pizza
Kwadwo B.• 11/15/23great value and taste
gisselle M.• 10/15/23Delicioso ❤️
Julio L.• 10/03/23I have never seen a pizza quite like this before it tasted so delicious it was sweet it was crispy but most of all it had the best temperature ever. I enjoy the milkshake as well it was very delicious.
Rafael D.• 09/24/23Las mejores pizzas
Joshua C.• 09/08/23Easy pickup
CYNTHIA L.• 08/28/23best pizza ever!
Vince W.• 08/17/23The food is amazing!!! I love their pizza!
Alex H.• 08/12/23Pizza was good
Jordan B.• 08/03/23Great Zza brah!
Lauren C.• 08/03/23so flavorful
JULIAN A.• 07/28/23Some of the best pizza I’ve ever eaten. Native NYer here and I’ve tried so much pizza. Top 3 for sure
Debbie P.• 07/20/23Great pizza
Kisha W.• 07/13/23Food was delicious and cooked perfectly.
Anthony P.• 06/24/23dope pizza
Van J.• 06/02/23Very good pizza versus price, delicious!
Fion W.• 04/21/23Delicious
Nicole C.• 04/14/23awesome pizza delicious 😋
FRANCIS S.• 03/25/23best ultimate pizza ever, very addictive
Marco M.• 02/10/23It was very tasty
ida F.• 12/01/22Literally a staple. Best pizza I’ve had in a while
jose T.• 06/13/22Delicious
James H.• 02/02/25The Uber delivery was fast courteous and professional. Great customer service!
Gary M.• 11/29/24Really delicious! Highly recommended!
Isidora V.• 11/15/24entrega muy rapida
Fulei N.• 07/17/24This was some of the best pizza I’ve had hands down. The sweet onion sauce was a sweet surprise!
Ricardo C.• 07/06/24This pizza is absolutely amazing...I love it!!!!
Quinlynn S.• 06/15/24amazing pizza and sandwich
Lauren C.• 05/22/24yummy deal
Ricardo C.• 05/08/24This pizza is soooo good!!!!
Hannah J.• 05/01/24The #11 is my absolute favorite. It sounds silly but I always order from here on a bad day, because something about it always makes me feel better! I don’t know how they do it, but these are so delicious!!!! There are many pizzas out there, but this one is always 10/10 stars for me. So thank you! ✨😋 don’t forget to order a shake too!
Evan S.• 04/12/24yum
ahmad S.• 04/03/24great
Ashish R.• 03/23/24Great service and packing. Super tasty pizza
MASANORI H.• 03/17/24fast!
Keisha R.• 03/09/24Best
Adam S.• 02/19/24Fresh and tasty
Leonardo M.• 02/17/24Delicious 🤤
Salena L.• 02/12/24awesome
Ricardo C.• 02/06/24OMG this pizza is so good!
MAGGIE R.• 02/05/24So delicious and yummy!
Adam S.• 01/01/24Delish
Jody S.• 01/23/24Good pizza and amazing shakes!
Gabriel P.• 12/26/23excellent pizza!
Rachel Z.• 12/11/23Stunning food
ANTOINE W.• 12/06/23Delicious pizza
Crystal L.• 11/29/23love this place!!
Yasmeena C.• 10/20/23Yummy
Mike O.• 10/14/23Great toppings and milkshakes!
Kenneth M.• 09/29/23Great Pizza
Dharmendra S.• 09/26/23Loved the taste of both the quatreto pizza and the cookies and cream shake!
Gabe P.• 09/22/23It was completely amazing
Christian K.• 08/28/23Amazing food! The office staff love the quality and taste.
Lauren C.• 08/18/23yum
주영 전.• 08/13/23양이 많아 좋습니다
CYNTHIA L.• 08/05/23I have lived in many states and this is the best pizza I've ever had!
Marie Louise F.• 08/03/23First time ordering and OMG this pizza was so amazing! Will definitely order again.
Rubens L.• 07/26/23Big portion
Jafar M.• 07/24/23Good
Shah C.• 07/17/23it was delicious
Sonali R.• 07/04/23Well packed and full of flavor
Alex G.• 06/23/23Delicious
Quintus M.• 05/19/23Fast service
Daisuke S.• 04/20/23Solid abc delicious
Ben U.• 04/01/23top shelf authentic taste... call it Listo slice of Italy
ABHISEK J.• 03/06/23Quick and affordable
Sanj R.• 02/01/23First time ordering from beee but the pizzas and shake were great!
Kamilah M.• 09/12/22The hot honey pizza is amazing!
Can I order Pizza & Shakes delivery in New York with Uber Eats?
Yes. Pizza & Shakes delivery is available on Uber Eats in New York.
Is Pizza & Shakes delivery available near me?
Enter your address to see if Pizza & Shakes delivery is available to your location in New York.
How do I order Pizza & Shakes delivery online in New York?
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the Pizza & Shakes menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
Where can I find Pizza & Shakes online menu prices?
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by Pizza & Shakes here on this page.
How do I get free delivery on my Pizza & Shakes order?
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
How do I pay for my Pizza & Shakes order?
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
What’s the best thing to order for Pizza & Shakes delivery in New York?
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your Pizza & Shakes order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.
