4.8
1000+ Ratings
Brooklyn South
4.8 x (1,000+) • 1019.6 mi • Sandwiches • American • Healthy • Deli • Alcohol • $ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
1437 Central Avenue
Delivery
Pickup
Rating and reviews
"This is always what I want when I crave a sandwich. The bread is hands-down the best in St Pete. I usually do UberEats, but when you do pop into the store, they're always happy to give recommendations on food or cheeses that they sell. Definitely worth it."
• Danielle S. • 03/03/22
"wow what a great sandwich! I tried the Italian as it appears on the menu. The bread was fresh and perfectly toasted. Fresh ingredients, great flavor! Can't wait to visit them at their in-person location."
• Jessica Leigh E. • 03/01/23
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Delivery unavailable
Delivery time
Sunday
12:30 PM - 6:45 PM
Monday - Saturday
10:30 AM - 6:45 PM
Hot Prepared Food
- House Mac and Cheese Small$6.99 • 90% (239)Our house-made Mac and Cheese made with a delicious variety of blended cheeses.
- Soup of the Day$5.99 • 96% (59)special house made soup (Chicken and vegetables, Lentil with veggies and pork, or Bean with veggies and pork) All may not be available.
- House Mac & Cheese Large$9.99 • 94% (77)Our house-made Mac and Cheese made with a delicious variety of blended cheeses.
Sandwiches
- Breuben$12.99 • 92% (169)Brooklyn South version of Reuben! served with Corned Beef, Sauerkraut, Peter Luger mayo. (Try it with Sliced Roasted Turkey!)#3 most liked
- 1437 Cuban$14.25 • 93% (197)Served with Ham, Pork Loin, Hot Capicola, Provolone, pickles and garlic-cilantro mayo#1 most liked
- Tuna Salad$13.79 • 93% (78)Mediterranean Tuna Salad with Capers and Lemon, Swiss Cheese, and a Mustard-Mayo base#2 most liked
- Italian$14.25 • 95% (272)Chef’s choice of meats, Red Roasted Pepper, Mozzarella and Basil Pesto
- Turkey Fig$11.99 • 99% (229)Served with Roasted turkey, Cheddar Cheese and Fig Preserves
- Ropa Vieja Melt$14.25 • 97% (42)Seasoned Cuban style pulled beef, Provolone
- Rosemary Chicken$11.99Served with fresh Mozzarella and a Mustard-Mayo base
- Beef Brisket$14.25Served with Provolone cheese, sautéed peppers and onions, Peter Luger mayo)
- Grilled Veggie Melt$13.99 • 98% (75)Served with Portabello Mushrooms, Roasted Peppers, Spinach, Fresh Goat Cheese, and Basil Pesto
- All-Day Egg$9.99 • 94% (69)Served with bacon, two eggs, cheese, and caramelized onions
- 1437 Ham$13.79 • 95% (86)Served with Caramelized Apples, Brie Cheese and a Mustard-Mayo base.
- Jerk Chicken$12.99 • 95% (42)Brooklyn South version! Seasoned Jamaican Style Chicken, Fresh Mozzarella and Tomato
- Turkey Mango$10.99Served with Roasted Turkey, Cheddar Cheese and Mango Chutney
- Three Cheese Grilled Cheese$9.99With cheddar, provolone and mozzarella
- Corned Beef$13.99 • 98% (51)Served with Peter Luger sauce, Roasted Red Peppers, and Vermont Cheddar
- Fig and Cheddar$7.99 • 95% (42)Grilled cheese with Fig Jam and Cheddar Cheese
- Pulled Pork$14.25 • 92% (28)Vinegar, Apple and Carrot cabbage slaw, Provolone cheese and mustard mayo blend
Snacks and Sides
Drinks
Dessert
special
Beer
- Rating and reviews
4.8
•1000+ Ratings •
22 Reviews
Channelle H.• 06/10/24They accommodated my customizations and the flavor was amazing!
Capt. Charlie W.• 05/26/24Delicious
BETH O.• 03/07/24Sandwich was smashing!!!! Definitely ordering again!
Richard M.• 02/02/24BROOKLYN SOUTH IS THE BEST! THEY ALWAYS COME THROUGH IN THE CLUTCH FOR OUR OFFICE LUNCHES. PACKAGED PERFECTLY AND ON TIME. 10 STARS!
Lindsey H.• 11/19/23awesome!!
Sonya S.• 10/25/23Crazy how good these sandwiches were. Ready to order again!
Natalie M.• 09/23/23Delicious and fresh!
Erin D.• 08/16/23Had to call to make a modification and they were incredibly friendly
Fawnia S.• 08/13/23Delicious and quick
Debbie H.• 08/05/23Great Mac and cheese!
Sierra A.• 06/14/23good mac n cheese
Craig P.• 05/01/23I’m terrified of the ravenous monster I’ve become having discovered this mouth watering gem.
Rishi C.• 05/18/23Really tasty and filling sandwiches.
Jessica Leigh E.• 03/01/23wow what a great sandwich! I tried the Italian as it appears on the menu. The bread was fresh and perfectly toasted. Fresh ingredients, great flavor! Can't wait to visit them at their in-person location.
Emily K.• 03/28/23Delicious
Andrea M.• 12/21/22My turkey and ghostpepper cheese sandwich and Mac n cheese was so yummy!
Danielle S.• 03/03/22This is always what I want when I crave a sandwich. The bread is hands-down the best in St Pete. I usually do UberEats, but when you do pop into the store, they're always happy to give recommendations on food or cheeses that they sell. Definitely worth it.
Michael C.• 11/22/21Perfect
Peter P.• 10/21/21Very tasty
Walter B.• 10/16/21The Cuban sandwich is among the best I have ever eaten.
Brian C.• 10/13/21Always great!
Corey S.• 07/18/21Impressive and unpretentious.
