4.7
2000+ Ratings
Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry
4.7 x (2,000+) • 1994.7 km • Pizza • American • Wings • Family Friendly • $ • Info
x Delivery unavailable
1455 State Road 436
Delivery
Pickup
Located in Casselberry, Anthony's NY Pizza offers a variety of New York-style pizzas along with an assortment of Italian-American dishes. The menu features classics such as large and medium cheese pizzas, along... More
Located in Casselberry, Anthony's NY Pizza offers a variety of New York-style pizzas along with an assortment of Italian-American dishes. The menu features classics such as large and medium cheese pizzas, alongside customizable options with a diverse range of toppings. Popular items among patrons include the 18" X-Large Cheese Pizza, 14" Create Your Own Pizza, and savory Garlic Knots. The establishment also serves a selection of appetizers, salads, hot and cold subs, desserts, and beverages, catering to a broad range of tastes and preferences. With a customer rating rounding to 4.3, this pizzeria is a favored choice during the evening hours. Less
Rating and reviews
"Best pizza that is not homemade by my son hahaha. And their extra large is actually...extra large! Also great prices. My new fave for delivered pizza."
• HEIDI K. • 07/29/23
"Eggplant rollatini was so good. Reminded me of my own. So flavorful and cheesy. Pizza is great too. This is my go to place when ordering out. Great food."
• kayla S. • 06/02/22
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Delivery unavailable
Delivery time
Sunday
11:45 AM - 9:00 PM • Appetizers
11:45 AM - 9:00 PM • Salads
11:45 AM - 9:00 PM • Pizza
11:45 AM - 9:00 PM • Calzones & Strombolis
11:45 AM - 9:00 PM • Entrees
11:45 AM - 9:00 PM • Hot & Cold Subs
11:45 AM - 9:00 PM • Sides
11:45 AM - 9:00 PM • Kids
11:45 AM - 9:00 PM • Desserts
11:45 AM - 9:00 PM • Beverages
Monday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Appetizers
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Salads
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Pizza
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Calzones & Strombolis
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Entrees
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Hot & Cold Subs
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Sides
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Kids
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Desserts
11:00 AM - 9:00 PM • Beverages
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM • Appetizers
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM • Salads
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM • Pizza
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM • Calzones & Strombolis
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM • Entrees
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM • Hot & Cold Subs
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM • Sides
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM • Kids
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM • Desserts
11:00 AM - 10:00 PM • Beverages
Pizza by the Slice
- Meat Lovers Slice$7.31 • 66% (3)
- Veggie Slice$7.31Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes, black olives, and extra cheese
- Bianca Slice$3.65Mozzarella cheese, fresh garlic, olive oil, and ricotta cheesePopular
- Extravaganza Slice$7.31Extra cheese, pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and meatballs
- Mediterranean Slice$7.31Spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, mozzarella cheese, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, black olives, and fresh garlic
Pizza - 12" Small Pizzas
- 12" Hawaiian Pizza$19.51Ham, pineapple
- 12" Pepperoni Pizza$21.00 • 85% (7)Six slices!#3 most liked
- 12" Create Your Own$13.41 • 100% (15)6 slices
- 12" Gluten Free Cheese Pizza$17.07
- 12" Anthony's Extravaganza Pizza$20.73Extra cheese, pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, meatballs
- 12" Anthony's Meat Lovers Pizza$20.73Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, ham, bacon, extra cheese
- 12" Anthony's Veggie Pizza$19.46Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes, black olives, and extra cheese
- 12" Bianca Pizza$18.29Mozzarella cheese, fresh garlic, olive oil, and ricotta cheese
- 12" Mediterranean Pizza$21.95Spinach, broccoli, mushrooms, mozzarella cheese, onions, green peppers, tomatoes, black olives, and fresh garlic
- 12" Margherita Pizza$19.51Grande mozzarella cheese, tomatoes, olive oil, garlic, basil, Parmesan cheese
Pizza - 14" Medium Pizzas
- 14" Create Your Own$17.07 • 83% (12)8 slices
- 14" Anthony's Extravaganza Pizza$28.05Extra cheese, pepperoni, sausage, green peppers, mushrooms, onions, and meatballs
- 14" Anthony's Meat Lovers Pizza$28.05Pepperoni, sausage, meatballs, ham, bacon, and extra cheese
- 14" Anthony's Veggie Pizza$28.05Mushrooms, green peppers, onions, tomatoes, black olives, and extra cheese
- 14" Hawaiian Pizza$21.95Ham & pineapple
Pizza - 16" Large Pizzas
Pizza - 18" Extra Large Pizzas
- Rating and reviews
4.7
•2000+ Ratings •
70 Reviews
Deana J.• 05/24/24Best Italian restaurant in town. Everything on the menu is delicious.
mary M.• 04/23/24great
Esther L.• 04/20/24We love the Pizza from Anthony’s. Reminds us of the delicious pizza in NY! Grazie!
KRISTOPHER M.• 03/09/24Small business big flavor. Casselberry staple.
Carolena P.• 03/02/24Very nice 😊
Isaac M.• 02/17/24Pizza was good but the wings were surprisingly great.
Kathy B.• 02/16/24Good pizza
Jessica L.• 01/20/24everything was delicious. I dream about the sauce used on the pizza. the salad is always perfect.
Christina H.• 12/29/23It was great! Thanks!
Al Tarek W.• 12/17/23Pizza was Fire
Bradley H.• 12/17/23Great food
carol F.• 11/29/23The delivery was timely.
Deanna Y.• 11/27/23Best pizza place in all of north Orlando - the cheese, red sauce, dough, all of it!
Taylor C.• 11/24/23Yes
Jake S.• 11/18/23Haven’t really had better pizza in Orlando - simple and delicious
Nic A.• 11/10/23Oh my god this place is amazing, and the portions last me two days or so I am so glad i found them
Melissa M.• 11/06/23Everything is always good!
Michel C.• 10/12/23excellent communication
Kathleen F.• 10/11/23Excellent eggplant parm! Very tasty, big portions and arrived very hot. Highly recommend!
Richard T.• 10/07/23Great real NY pizza!!
Bradley H.• 10/02/23Always tasty and the staff is friendly. If you are in the winter park/Castleberry area it’s a good option.
Melissa M.• 09/23/23We love this Anthony's!
Melissa M.• 09/21/23We always enjoy it.
Eileen P.• 09/19/23taste great
lisa G.• 09/10/23Tasty good.
Alviz L.• 09/01/23really good taste and huge
Mark W.• 08/27/23Great food for a great price.
Michael L.• 08/26/23great pizza!
Rhinemark V.• 08/23/23Best pizza in town!
DIANNE R.• 08/11/23Tastes absolutely delicious!!
Tiffany M.• 08/07/23Perfect everytime
Bridghid D.• 07/29/23Anthony’s has been favorite local pizza for years
HEIDI K.• 07/29/23Best pizza that is not homemade by my son hahaha. And their extra large is actually...extra large! Also great prices. My new fave for delivered pizza.
Filipe Z.• 07/24/23Excellent pizza
keir V.• 07/22/23Great food
Kim M.• 07/09/23I ordered the eggplant parmesan with spaghetti. it came with salad and garlic knots. it was absolutely delicious and a very generous portion.
Michael K.• 07/09/23Pound for pound, best and most consistent.
Melody C.• 06/30/23The cheese pizza has excellent cheese flavor and good cheese to tomato sauce ratio.
Chris L.• 06/28/23First time customer. Very impressed with quality of pizza and garlic bread w/cheese! Will be back for more!!
Pamela B.• 06/24/23Best NY style pizza in Central Florida!
Melissa S.• 06/24/23Delicious!
Ron K.• 06/17/23very good, foldable crust and not too salty either
Michael L.• 06/09/23pizza's perfect sausage was delicious!
joel H.• 06/07/23Great taste
Stef C.• 06/05/23Best chicken parm and red sauce. I love their bianca pizza. Good house salad with the best ranch.
Lauretha R.• 06/04/23Delicious
Denise D.• 06/04/23Great pizza
Melissa S.• 06/02/23Delicious
Michael L.• 05/27/23good sauce!
Kimberley R.• 05/19/23Pizza never disappoints
Deana J.• 04/22/23Best Italian in Central Florida!
Heather P.• 04/16/23Food was good - large portions. Yummy garlic knots! Will purchase from here again.
kayla S.• 03/27/23best pizza in FL! their subs and pasta dishes are great too.
Melissa M.• 03/24/23Always great food!
Oliver J.• 02/28/23I love eating here the wings, pizza, and pasta is good yum!!!
Kathryn M.• 02/27/23So delicious! Don’t sleep on the subs; fresh and soooo good!
kayla S.• 02/14/23Best pizza in Orlando and that's coming from a New Yorker!
Nicholas M.• 02/06/23Best NY Style pizza in Orlando. Can't beat it.
MARCUS L.• 01/22/23awesome service and food
Shane B.• 12/23/22Delicious
Shane B.• 12/10/22Amazing pizza
Marcos R.• 10/27/22Delicious, the best Pizza in Casselberry.
Reinaldo B.• 10/01/22Excellent
Emmanuel C.• 09/20/22best pizza in altamonte springs period!
Konstance S.• 07/05/22Love the pizza.
kayla S.• 06/16/22Closest to NY pizza that I've had here in FL. My go to spot.
kayla S.• 06/02/22Eggplant rollatini was so good. Reminded me of my own. So flavorful and cheesy. Pizza is great too. This is my go to place when ordering out. Great food.
Mike G.• 05/15/22Great customer service, fast delivery , amazing pizza
Christopher M.• 02/13/22Awesome
Luz R.• 09/20/21Delicious 😋
Can I order Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry delivery in Casselberry with Uber Eats?
Yes. Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry delivery is available on Uber Eats in Casselberry.
Is Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry delivery available near me?
Enter your address to see if Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry delivery is available to your location in Casselberry.
How do I order Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry delivery online in Casselberry?
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
Where can I find Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry online menu prices?
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry here on this page.
How do I get free delivery on my Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry order?
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
How do I pay for my Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry order?
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
What’s the best thing to order for Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry delivery in Casselberry?
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your Original Anthony's NY Pizza - Casselberry order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.
