4.6
2000+ Ratings
4.6 x (2,000+) • 2389.1 mi • Italian • Pasta • Pizza • Exclusive to Eats • Group Friendly • $ • Info
3523 49th St N
2000+ Ratings
"Since I moved to St. Pete in 1993 I will not eat pizza or calzones from anywhere else - their subs are simple but also delish! Toby's has had a reputation (from some of my St. Pete native friends) for being the best since it opened. However, I can honestly say it has been the best pizza and calzones anywhere south of New York I have ever had."
"Food is always good, thank you for being ONE establishment in the area I can consistently rely on for delicious and accurate food. I personally have found it near impossible in St. Pete to get, both, good and correct food, but Toby’s never misses. Thank you!"
x $0 delivery fee
new customers
Enter address
to see delivery time
11:00 AM - 9:30 PM
11:00 AM - 10:30 PM
4.6
•2000+ Ratings •
179 Reviews
By far, it is the best pizza I've had in a long time.
local
great
The best salad!
great pizza! great salad! the garlic knots are the best.
Good food and service
Best pizza and subs in town
best pizza in the city
best pizza ever!
😍 Goddess
fresh Everytime.
One of the best cheesesteaks around!
awesome place
Great pizza crispy with delivery!
Always delicious. Enjoyed their pizza since I was a kid, no other options come close.
Great food and service
Consistently great!
Yum
Everything was great
love the bience when I went to pick it up. food was delicious and you can tell the workers care about the product!
Solid NY style pizza at the beach
Best pizza in st Pete!!
best f****** pizza around
Amazing pizza
Toby’s is New York pizza!!
Best pizza outside of NY!
Philly cheese steak with onion was great! If I had the option to add green peppers to it I would! Delicious!
who doesn't love Tobys? always good food.
True Italian. Hot, fresh and excellent!
Great sandwich. Pretty girl. Hands me a hot sandwich in front of the bus stop.
They read notes, good size, and cheaper than most, taste yummy.
The best pizza and antipasto salad I’ve ever had in Florida!!!
Hot, excellent all-the-way cheese steaks.
best Italian in town
Excellent food
This is the best pizza in St Pete hands down.
Been eating from there for over 20 years. Reminds me of home, Brooklyn. 😊
one of the best pizzas and subs we have had in years.
Excellent pizza
best
Delicious!
Enormous and delicious
The food is delicious
Great food
Best pizza in Pinellas County hands down
Above and beyond!
Fantastic !!!!
Pizza was delish
Always the Best!
Toby’s is the best pizza in St Pete.
Quick and affordable
Love this place
Best ever staff and food fave place to be.
Thank you. Have a wonderful Holiday
The best pizza in Pinellas county.
Everything tasted great as usual! The young brunette at the front deserves a raise!!
Fresh!
Freaking awesome Sicilian every time TY
the food is so wonderful and delicious I'm from Philly and the Philly cheese steak is great they give you great portions and you feel like it was home cooked very very delicious love it
Great
The pizza was delicious and the delivery driver was perfect!
Very good pizza!
The best pizza ever
Grata pizza!
hot food
really good
Food is consistently good.
Food is always good, thank you for being ONE establishment in the area I can consistently rely on for delicious and accurate food. I personally have found it near impossible in St. Pete to get, both, good and correct food, but Toby’s never misses. Thank you!
Best pizza around!!!
Amazing as usual. Best place to get a Philly or pie in st.petersburg!
great food great employees
Excellent pizza
Best pizza!!
always amazing food
love the large portions and excellent quality ingredients
Garlic knots are to die for.
Love this place and everything they make. First bite was in 1993!
Awesome, Pizza as always!
huge portions, very fresh and well made, absolutely delicious, thank you!
Since I moved to St. Pete in 1993 I will not eat pizza or calzones from anywhere else - their subs are simple but also delish! Toby's has had a reputation (from some of my St. Pete native friends) for being the best since it opened. However, I can honestly say it has been the best pizza and calzones anywhere south of New York I have ever had.
Very good
Haven't had pizza this good since I was actually IN Italy. Grazie!!!!
Hot and tasty
Toby’s is hands down the BEST pizza in Pinellas County
Best Pizza in Florida
Awesome subs, great pizza. Consistently delicious.
excellent. huge portions
Best Sicilian pizza!
Excellent pizza, subs, and antipasto salad.
Great pizza and cheesesteak.
Shout out to whoever is working the grill tonight! Hands down the best steak and cheese sub!
Might be the best pizza I've had since moving from NY to FL, and I've tried a lot of places
great food
its been the best for decades
Been eating here for 50 years!!
great authentic style pizza and garlic knots
Awesomeness
Live the steak and cheese sub. Delicious
Some great
loved the antipasto
Good pizza and meatball sub good delivery service will be our favorite restaurant
Best pizza ever !!! Family staple for years
the best
great food
always awesome
good pizza 🍕
Best pizza in town and I mean that. Closest to a New York Style.
Great pizza, some of the best around
True, New York style pizza even down to the large slices.
Food is always delicious!!
yes
All the years been having pizza and subs,always the best!!!!!!
Awesome food 👍
Great Service
Great pizza and subs
Best Pizza in St. Pete very generous with the toppings!!!
They have my favorite custom pizza as a signature item and it’s real gud
good quality pizza and the garlic knots are outstanding
Eat garlic knots!
Fast, friendly and very worth the price food!!! The Antipasto salad and Garlic Knots are to die for!!!
great food
Great Pizza and best steak and cheese!!!
one of the best pizza shops around.
The food was amazing.
This was so amazing. Legit the snack I needed on a bad day. Been going here since I was kid, (legit used to walk like 20 blocks in Florida summer with my siblings to get it) and it’s still my favorite ❤️
best cheese steak and mushroom hoagie ever
Great za!
Look no further, if you're looking for the best pizza in town!!!
Great portions🍕
Best pizza in st Pete
love the sicilian
pizza was sooooo good and steak and cheese was out of this world!!!!
Awesome food
Toby's is one of our favorite places
Yum
great food
Always good and fresh
Sicilian pie was 🔥🔥
delicious. great pizza and garlic knots to die for
Good
the best and most authentic New York style pizzeria in St. Petersburg
Always delicious
Delicious
Delicious
DELICIOUS, ALWAYS!
great pizza
Always good. Never has changed. Always spot on.
I have ordered from here for years. They are the best pizza and calzones in town.
Always the best!!
just as good as ny pizza :)
Simply the best NY Style pizza in St Pete and I have been loving it for decades
best pizza
best always
they have the best Italian pizza in the city !
Best Pizza around. Hands down.
always great
I have been eating here since I moved here in 2009. it's delicious and fresh
amazing!
the best NY style pie in St. Pete!
The beat pizza for years.
Best pizza I had in Florida that taste like it’s just from New York
I’ve been eating here before I could walk. Loved when my parents would bring home the garlic knots and the cheese pizza. Lots of happy memories. I’m thankful I can get it delivered to my house now :)
delicious
Really the best NY style pizza and subs around!!
Great food
amazing pizza
Always amazing, a St. Pete staple
Again the best,what a lasagna! Never the less and always the best!!!!!!!
Best pizza around its always a line out the door that's when you know its good!!!
The best pizza in St Pete
A piece of St Pete - delish and really consistent.
No matter how many different pizza places I try I always come back to Little Italy. Definitely the best pizza in Pinellas.
Pizza was good and the salad I ordered was so good I've been craving it ever since.
Great Food and prices
tasty
Awesome pizza!
yummy
Food is delicious! Never disappointed! Garlic knots amazingggggggg
Thin crust and fresh
Yes. Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza delivery is available on Uber Eats in Saint Petersburg.
Enter your address to see if Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza delivery is available to your location in Saint Petersburg.
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza here on this page.
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your Toby's Original Little Italy Pizza order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.