4.8
500+ Ratings
American Pie Pizzeria
4.8 x (500+) • $3 Delivery Fee • 2650.7 mi • American • Pizza • Pasta • Italian • Info
x Delivered by store staff
2044 Montauk Highway
American Pie Pizzeria, located in Water Mill, is a pizza restaurant offering a diverse menu that caters to various tastes and dietary preferences. Customers particularly enjoy the Classic Cheese Pizza and Ultra... More
American Pie Pizzeria, located in Water Mill, is a pizza restaurant offering a diverse menu that caters to various tastes and dietary preferences. Customers particularly enjoy the Classic Cheese Pizza and Ultra Thin Pizza, alongside the specialty Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza. The restaurant also serves a variety of appetizers, including the popular Garlic Knots, and a selection of entrees, pastas, and salads like the Classic Caesar Salad. With a solid customer rating, it's a go-to spot in the evenings for those craving Italian-American cuisine. Less
Get it delivered to your door.
Rating and reviews
"Thank you for the quality and asked delivery"
• liz M. • 02/14/24
"Fresh ingredients and quick delivery."
• Susan L. • 09/08/23
$3 Delivery Fee
Pricing & fees
Enter address
to see delivery time
Sunday - Thursday
11:00 AM - 8:45 PM
Friday - Saturday
11:00 AM - 9:45 PM
Featured items
Pizza
- Classic Cheese Pizza$24.99 • 96% (100)Large 18" round classic NYC style with a thin crispy crust.
- Gluten Free Cauliflower Crust Pizza$16.99 • 88% (26)Personal 10" crust.Gluten Free
- Grandma Pizza$28.99 • 88% (17)Thin square crispy crust, light cheese, and with hand crushed garlic marinara and fresh basil.
- Ultra Thin Pizza$12.99 • 91% (35)Personal 10" paper thin crust made regular or whole wheat.
- Sicilian Pizza$28.99 • 66% (3)Large square thick crust topped with mozzarella and a traditional Sicilian tomato sauce.
Specialty Pies
- Margherita$28.99 • 80% (21)Traditional Italian pie with home-made fresh mozzarella, tomato sauce, and fresh basil.
- Chicken Bacon Ranch Pizza$42.99Loaded with diced chicken breast , diced tomatoes, cheddar, and mozzarella cheeses
- White Pie Pizza$28.99Mozzarella, ricotta, and romano with a hint of garlic.
- Grandma Alla Vodka Pizza$36.99 • 100% (5)Grandma crust with fresh mozzarella and vodka sauce.
- Meat Lovers Pizza$34.99Italian sweet sausage, ham, home-made meatballs, and pepperoni.Popular
- Hawaiian Pizza$29.99 • 85% (7)Ham and pineapple.
- Vegetarian Pizza$31.99Roasted mushrooms, onions, roasted red and green peppers, broccoli, spinach, Parmesan, and garlic (no red sauce).Popular
- Buffalo Chicken Pizza$42.99Loaded with diced all white meat chicken breast, hot sauce w/ blue cheese dressing and mozzarella cheese.
- BBQ Chicken Pizza$42.99Loaded with white meat chicken breast, sweet and tangy BBQ sauce, cheddar and mozzarella cheeses.
- Brooklyn Style Sicilian Pizza$28.99Sicilian style thick square crust, hand crushed marinara over mozzarella, and finished with grated Parmesan.
- Taco Pizza$34.99Seasoned ground Angus beef, shredded lettuce, shredded cheese blend, diced tomatoes, and tortilla chips.
- Philly Cheese Steak Pizza$34.99Thinly sliced Philly steak, onions, peppers, provolone, and mozzarella.
- Chicken Parmigiana Pizza$42.99 • 100% (4)Breaded chicken cutlet with mozzarella and our house tomato sauce.
- Penne Alla Vodka Pizza$32.99With prosciutto and fresh basil.
- Eggplant Rollatini Pizza$34.99Eggplant, ricotta, mozzarella, and marinara.
Appetizers
Pasta
Baked Pasta
American Heros
Entrees
Salads
Side Orders
Soups
Wraps
Grilled Panini
Pizza Rolls & Calzones
Beverages
Dessert
- Rating and reviews
4.8
•500+ Ratings •
7 Reviews
Katherine P.• 03/08/24It slay
liz M.• 02/14/24Thank you for the quality and asked delivery
Janeli O.• 12/13/23Great
Eustorgio R.• 10/05/23Is good
Susan L.• 09/08/23Fresh ingredients and quick delivery.
Jen M.• 07/21/23Perfect.
John D.• 06/29/23Very consistent
Can I order American Pie Pizzeria delivery in Water Mill with Uber Eats?
Yes. American Pie Pizzeria delivery is available on Uber Eats in Water Mill.
Is American Pie Pizzeria delivery available near me?
Enter your address to see if American Pie Pizzeria delivery is available to your location in Water Mill.
How do I order American Pie Pizzeria delivery online in Water Mill?
There are 2 ways to place an order on Uber Eats: on the app or online using the Uber Eats website. After you’ve looked over the American Pie Pizzeria menu, simply choose the items you’d like to order and add them to your cart. Next, you’ll be able to review, place, and track your order.
Where can I find American Pie Pizzeria online menu prices?
View upfront pricing information for the various items offered by American Pie Pizzeria here on this page.
How do I get free delivery on my American Pie Pizzeria order?
To save money on the delivery, consider getting an Uber One membership, if available in your area, as one of its perks is a $0 Delivery Fee on select orders.
How do I pay for my American Pie Pizzeria order?
Payment is handled via your Uber Eats account.
What’s the best thing to order for American Pie Pizzeria delivery in Water Mill?
If you’re in need of some suggestions for your American Pie Pizzeria order, check out the items showcased in “Picked for you” on this page.
